Transcript 0:00 We were trying to rationalize meme stock rallies. You know, what's happening? Why do they occur? What is prompting that kind of behavior, right? And, you know, and, and the traditional narration in the market's about it. 0:10 And you know what? When we started polling and talking to our customers, [notification sound] we came up with a few conclusions, you know. 0:16 And, and the, the, and the idea is that it's just not a millennial or a, or a Gen Z phenomenon. [on-hold music] On this episode of Early Bird, Dan Raju, co-founder and CEO of Tradiea. 0:32 Dan joins the podcast today to talk about the past, present, and future of meme stock rallies, including some interesting investing data. 0:42 If you're an investor looking to stay on top of the latest market trends, then you're listening to the right podcast. This is Early Bird, and I'm your host, Steven Lerner. 0:52 Before we get to today's discussion, let me tell you how you can save time and beat the market through Early Bird, a free daily email newsletter featuring commentary about the latest trends in stocks, cryptocurrency, and equity crowdfunding. 1:08 Early Bird is designed to help individual and non-professional investors stay on top of all of the critical investing trends. The newsletter is one hundred percent free and is sent to your email box each weekday morning. 1:22 Subscribe to Early Bird for free at www.earlybird.email. Once again, that's earlybird.email. And now, today's discussion. All right, Dan, welcome to the Early Bird podcast. Thank you for coming on today. 1:39 How are you doing? I'm doing great, Steven. How are you? I'm doing wonderful, thank you. 1:44 Today, we're going to take a look at some data, looking at the potential future of meme rallies as they pertain in the stock market. We'll take a look at that in a second. 1:54 But first, Dan, tell the audience a little bit about yourself. If you could give a brief thirty-second, you know, background, biography about you and your company, I think that'd be great. Cool. No, I appreciate it. 2:07 Uh, thanks for having me, Steven. Um, Tradiea is one of the larger, what, what we call as embedded finance, um, players in the market. 2:16 What we do is, um, you know, we let, um, investing be unbundled and made available from hundreds of platforms today in the market. 2:27 So if you think about, um, uh, in a hub-and-spoke kind of a world, over three hundred companies in the market today, uh, who are providing retail investing platforms use Tradiea to power their trading and their data and, and their, and, and, and all-- on all kinds of content on their, on their investing platforms. 2:47 So we tend to have a, a bird's eye view of what happens in the market. Um, each platform has its own view of what happens with-within its subs-- within its subset of the m-market, but we tend to have a broader view. 2:59 So happy to share the data. We're happy to share what we are seeing on the retail side. And my background is I'm one of the-- I'm the, uh, I'm, I'm a, I'm a co-founder and also CEO of the firm. 3:09 The firm is about eight years old, but close to nine years old at this time. And, uh, we are one of the larger, you know, active trading options brokers in the country. Nice. 3:19 Definitely great to have you on, Dan, uh, especially from Tradiea. It's a wonderful platform and, and firm. It's-- so it's wonderful to hear your insights and the data that you're seeing. 3:29 Um, so let, let, let's talk a little bit about this. Uh, before we go into the future of memes rallies, let's take a look at the past just a little bit. 3:37 You know, last year, twenty twenty-one, we saw some big meme stock rallies. Um, everybody in the market, uh, noticed this. 3:47 Um, from your standpoint in Tradiea, what did you see in the market at that point last year with the m- with the meme stock rally? No, see, this is the key. 3:57 To understand, uh, what's happening in the market particularly the last couple of years, right? I think, I think it's important for us, all of us, to have a few interesting data points in the market. 4:09 Um, you know, the US market right now has roughly around a hundred and twenty-ish million funded retail brokerage accounts. That's people putting in their own money, um, into, to investing in the market. 4:24 And out of that, close to twenty-five to twenty-six million of them just jumped into the market over the last four or five years. Mm. 4:32 So if you think about it, right, the market has grown by almost close to twenty to a twenty-five percent over the last... It's, it's, it's an industry that's been playing for obviously decades. 4:43 But in the last four or five years, you've seen almost a twenty-five percent raise. 4:47 Now, what happens is when so many people come into the market at one particular time, in a short period of time, and then they're exposed to a pandemic kind of a condition where, uh, millions of people are at home in front of their computers, probably nothing more to do than... 5:06 I mean, there's no gaming, there's no sports, and there's... and so stock market turned out to be one of the best locations that they could get active with. And the new cycles, you know, didn't hurt either. 5:17 So you have this hypersensitive, hypercyclic, and hyperactive almost incubation where hundreds of these folks jumped in. 5:27 Uh, actually, millions of these, uh, new traders came into the market, and that created a situation where a, a unique set of social behaviors that we call as meme stocks got created, right? 5:38 So the cause of the meme stocks that we see is the, the fundamental idea that, you know, a small subset or a large group of people who are socially collaborating and talking to each other and are trying to inver-- i-invest in short term in a few sets of stocks that have really no fundamentals behind it, but at the same time, they're buying and selling it in high volumes, um-That is what people call as meme stocks. 6:06 We-we-we saw m- a lot of that in twenty twenty. We see a slight slowdown in twenty twenty-one, and you're seeing this much more slowdown in twenty twenty-two. Far fewer, but still quite active, uh, in twenty twenty-two. 6:22 But, but that's what is fundamentally happening is this, this is, is unfundamental based, um, socially expressive, um, rallying behind direction by a small set of investors due to social communication. 6:37 But I look at that as more driven by the conditions, and as, as, as, as a graduation occurs, we see a, a much lesser and lesser of that. 6:45 We still are gonna see that for a while, but I just don't think we're gonna see as much as we saw in, in the last, uh, uh, [laughs] twenty twenty, twenty twenty-one. 6:53 Twenty twenty-two is still seeing that, but I expect it to taper off. Hmm. So it's a bit slower now. What-- Dan, what do you attribute that slowdown in meme stocks? 7:02 Is it because the overall market has declined in the past, uh, few months? Is it because, you know, a lot of tech stocks, high growth stocks are declining as well? 7:12 What, what do you attribute to the, uh, decline in meme stocks, uh, in twenty twenty-two? Yeah. See, they're two different things, right? I mean, meme stock prices are still high, right? 7:25 The number of meme stock rallies is, is coming down. 7:29 I mean, you know, it's, it's, uh, sometimes, you know, the market fundamentals versus where the, the prices of these meme stocks, I mean, don't, don't tally up in the right way. 7:38 But you still see a f- much fewer occurrences of these. And the reason you see fewer occurrences of these are driven by a few things, right? 7:47 Um, number one is, you know, we have gone through a fund m- We've, we've gone through an era where nothing went down for, for almost like twelve to thirteen years. It kept on going. 7:57 I mean, all you had to do was sit on the sides and the market grow. 8:00 That, that is being challenged at this time, particularly because of the interest rate hikes and, uh, and also, right, uh, the Fed's p- pursuance of trying to get inflation under control. That's number one. 8:12 And number two is I think there's a graduation effect, uh, for these traders too, Steven. Is they came into the market, they were kind of put underneath the gun to, to learn, and they learned. 8:24 They, they've got better at it, right? Um, and they have moved from playing wildly with less fundamentals to, uh, you know, trying to have, have, have gone through the, uh, through the fire once. 8:36 So you see a-- So it's a graduation effect, uh, number one, and number two is there is this, there is a slowdown, particularly the tech, right? And what happens fundamentally is when interest rates go up, right? 8:49 When interest rates go up, uh, people, you know, tend to take money out of, uh, uh, you know, people tend to take money out of tech because that's where I think the dividends have been, were be- were being paid for a long time. 9:01 And, you know, and so when interest rates go up, people tend to get out of tech a little bit. 9:05 And so all these factors combined, you know, people trying to get out of tech, the market also being, um, you know, t-t-taking a dive on a few days, uh, so the confidence kind of wanes a little bit. 9:16 And most importantly, they're going through a graduation effect, which is not a bad thing, but the net result is you have far fewer people who will do or are doing completely un- uh, investing with, with, with complete disregard to fundamentals. 9:29 They're getting to learn fundamentals a little better. 9:32 Uh, and, and, and, and, and one interesting thing I always talk when we talk about meme stock rallies is there is this common, um, what I call is, and I hate to say this, all of us in the market who are active in the media have kind of put this story out, that they are young, um, you know, mostly in the, um, Gen Zs, people in the eighteen to twenty-five-ish, or maybe, uh, in the millennials, you know, people from the twenty-five to thirty-five age range who are doing all this investing, and they're young and inexperienced. 10:03 That's just not true. I mean, what we see, uh, on these meme stock rallies is, you know, for example, the last couple of meme stock rallies we were tracking, you know, uh, I'll give you an interesting data point. 10:15 So, you know, people who are less than-- people who are between the age group of eighteen to thirty-five did twenty-four percent of the volume. 10:23 People from thirty-five to fifty did almost thirty-one percent of the volume, and people from fifty to sixty-five did thirty-four percent of the volume. 10:31 So I mean, if you take a look at it, right, it's, it's just not young millennial inexperienced people like the way the, the story has been laid out of, of people who are talking in Reddits and, you know, these forums and, and investing. 10:45 It is actually, um, it's actually a combination of people across all age groups who get involved into this. 10:51 So, but I, but, but, but I do see a tapering off of this kind of what we call as momentum-based meme stock runs because the market conditions have fundamentally changed. [upbeat music] Good to know. 11:08 When we return, we'll hear from Dan about the factors that might influence meme stock rallies in the next year. 11:16 But first, let me tell you where you can become a more informed investor through Early Bird, a free daily email newsletter. 11:24 Early Bird has commentary on the latest events and trends in stocks, cryptocurrency, and crowdfunding. With Early Bird's daily weekday email, investors can quickly stay on top of the trends and beat the market. 11:38 Subscribe to Early Bird for free at www.earlybird.email. Once again, that's earlybird.email. And now, back to today's discussion. So, uh, Dan, today we're talking about meme stocks, uh, and the meme stock rallies. 11:56 We talked about the past, the past and the present as, as it relates to this subject. Um, I wanna talk about the future a little bit, 'cause you have some really interesting data, um, at w- at your company, Tradea. 12:09 Um, what are you seeing as far as what the future of meme rallies might look like?Yeah, it's, it's hard to predict, right? It's hard to predict. 12:19 Uh, but I'll tell you some fundamental things we're seeing as it pertains to these rallies. Number one, Steven, and, and also retail in general, right? 12:28 Um, Steven, what we do see, like I said, is, um, because of the graduation effect that's occurring in the market, we s- we, we, we see some concentrated cases of, uh, meme stock rallies, but just not a broad spectrum application of that kind of a phenomena to every kind of trading. 12:46 So, uh, we are seeing some reduction. Uh, plus at the same time, uh, so I do expect, I do expect particularly around the Fed has announced, you know, they did two interest rate hikes. 13:01 They've announced probably-- They've announced four more. I, I, I, I fundamentally do not believe the Fed would do another four more. 13:09 I think the political pre-pressures of, uh, uh, would, would kick in very soon, and I just don't expect them to do four more. I do expect them to do a few. 13:18 Um, ar- in and around these, uh, interest rate hikes, I do see some volatility, and that volatility is feeding into some meme stock kind of behavior. 13:27 But, uh, but, but I see a lot of these behavior being focused around, in and around the interest rate fears and hikes and, and e- and, and excitement that comes in the market. 13:37 So that's what I see occurring in the next, you know, twelve months, number one. Um, number two, broadly in the market, we are seeing some fundamental changes. 13:47 Number one is, uh, the other thing that we're also seeing is that people are using, um, a lot more sophisticated kind of trading than they ever did. I mean, for example, options that we see in the market. 14:02 You know, traditionally, four, five, ten years ago, people would come into the market, they would trade, buy stock, sell a little bit, then they'd learn, and eventually they, they'll try to get into options. 14:14 We see that a lot more people are jumping into options so early. 14:18 In fact, we, we are seeing a tr- we are seeing almost that people graduate into doing options a few months after they just opened their first brokerage account. 14:27 So I think there is a mainstream adoption of options in the market. 14:31 And so if you take a look at that's the reason that explains the growth of firms like TradeYear and Robinhood and all these firms who have grown and who do ma- who do large amounts of volumes in the market. 14:41 So I see massive adoptions of options trading in the market. The third thing I also see is I think on the crypto side. 14:50 On the crypto side, I think, uh, what, what I expect to see over the next twelve months is crypto, which is traditionally not adopted as, as investment strategies by active traders, I see crypto being adopted. 15:03 Um, so I see that trend coming in, in the sense that crypto, which is largely, uh, traded by largely the, 15:10 the, the Gen Zs and the millennials, I see adoption much higher, um, in the age group sector of adoption of crypto. 15:18 And the last thing that I see, uh, and I see it in front of my eyes as, as far as crypto is concerned, so and the last thing I see, um, is internationalization of accounts. 15:27 One of the stuff that, you know, it'll be fascinating for us over the years to understand is, you know, 15:33 there is roughly around three million accounts that were opened last year, um, that are actually came from, um, that actually came from people outside the US who are opening brokerage accounts in the US. 15:45 So citizens of other countries opening accounts in the US brokerage market and trading US brokerage. So- Right. 15:52 It's kind of fascinating is because the geopolitical policies that occur, if three million people, which, which, which, uh, could be a concentrated force, who are impacted by political policy conditions outside the US are controlling the play in the market, that would be fascinating to watch. 16:09 So the main trends that I see is, you know, some more concentr- some, um, what I call as meme stock rallies around, uh, around, uh, interest rate hikes. 16:20 Um, I see continuation of massive amount of, uh, uh, options, which is a part of where people are graduating to advanced trading. 16:28 I see crypto, uh, spreading into the higher age age groups and internationalization of the US brokerage market. Mm. It's very interesting you brought that up, especially with crypto. 16:38 We know adoption is going through the roof e-even though prices of cryptos have declined a bit. Um, and- Right. Right. 16:44 And so what, what's interesting, what you bring up, you're saying, just so I understand, meme stocks in the next twelve months or so, the biggest factor will be interest rates, it sounds like, right? 16:57 I think they will be, they will be con-- I mean, the best that-- and I've been in the market for a long time. I've been doing this for almost seventeen, eighteen years at this time and almost at the forefront of retail. 17:08 I expect those rallies to be focused around the time areas where the interest rate hikes will occur. Yeah. Mm. 17:14 So i-i-in terms of timing, ju-just so I understand, you're saying when there is an interest rate hike, you think there's a chance where at that same time there might be some type of meme rally that occurs, right? Right. 17:28 In and around it. I mean, either it's happening just before or after that entire, uh, period around, around when the interest rate hikes occur. Yeah. Good. 17:37 It's, it's interesting where you can kind of see that from your data. You have a really good view of the market at TradeYa. 17:43 Um, there, there, there's one other piece of data that you do have that I also wanna just touch on very briefly. 17:48 I know you have some recent data about older generations that might be, uh, gravitating towards volatile stocks. Well, can you go over that briefly, just real quick? I think that's interesting. Yeah. 18:00 Let me, let me just-- And like, since you, you love data, it's kind of fascinating, right? Yeah. So, you know, you know, I, you know, you know, we were trying to rationalize meme stock rallies. 18:13 You know, what's happening? Why do they occur? What is prompting that kind of behavior, right?And, you know, and, and the traditional narration in the markets about it. And you know what? 18:22 When we started polling and talking to our customers, we came up with a few conclusions, you know? And, and the, the, and the idea is that it's just not a millennial or a, or a Gen Z phenomena, right? 18:33 For example, I'll give you some interesting data around this. Um, we polled roughly around... 18:39 We, we basically tracked around five thousand people who were basically what we thought were involved in and around the meme stock rally, uh, component of things, right? This is what we found, right? 18:49 Seventy percent of them were employed, fourteen percent of them were retired, five percent were self-employed, six percent of, was, were unemployed, and five percent were students. 19:00 So if you, if you see basically, um, the... So it kind of for me, you know, tells me that it's, it is, it is a kind of investing. 19:11 It is not the, the assumption that it is actually innocent and un- and innocent and non, and, uh, and unintentional investing is just not true. 19:21 I mean, you got people who are employed, you know, who are retired, and who are self-employed entrepreneurs participating in these rallies more. That's fascinating. Yeah. 19:31 Number two is if we take a look at the age groups of them, which, which I th- which I think you'll actually find it, uh, even more fa- even more fascinating, right? So if I basically took... 19:40 take a look at the age groups of these folks, what we found, like I was saying, was they're evenly spread. 19:47 You know, people in the age group fifty to sixty-five and, and th- thirty-five to fifty were, were doing just as much or, or more trading as than the people who are in the g- in, eh, than, [laughs] than the people in the eighteen to thirty-five. 20:02 So I think, um, meme stock is more a not... is, is, is, is not totally an age-driven phenomena, number one. It's also sometimes not totally, uh, what I call as, um, experience-driven. 20:19 I think what happens is that it, it, it is basically, um, it's actually more tr- you know, people taking a little bit of their money and trying to dedicate it to short-term momentum play. 20:34 And when you have enough people in the market that is, has grown in size by almost twenty-five percent come into play, you see these kind of behaviors. So, uh- Mm. 20:43 So the common perception that inexperienced traders are basically just participating in meme stock rallies, um, and, uh, is, is just not true. 20:52 [laughs] Well, it's good to know that all generations are participating in those types of rallies. That's interesting. 20:58 Uh, Dan, thank you so much for coming on the Early Bird Podcast today and, and presenting some data about, uh, meme stocks and, and the rallies we might see in the future. Thank you so much. I really appreciate it. 21:10 Uh, before we wrap up the podcast, I just have one final question, and it's the big question for today's discussion. 21:18 That question is, Dan, if you had your own late-night talk show, who would you invite as your first guest? 21:29 [laughs] I mean, I'll te- my first guest, my, my f- You know, I spent, for me, and I'm sure different people give a different answers to it, but for me, being in the retail markets and, and, and, and basically, you know, going ahead and spending so much of my time- Yeah. 21:48 I mean, I would invite, uh, I would invite Bill Capuzzi, the CEO of Apex Securities, um, to, to the podcast. I mean, you guys should get him on the show. 21:57 [laughs] He's just as much or more knowledgeable than I am about the retail markets. But if I ever have a podcast, obviously it's going to be on the retail markets. You should talk to the CEO of Apex, uh, Bill Capuzzi. 22:07 He has an interesting set of perspective, different than mine in some cases, but, uh, we tend to align in direction in most cases, so. Good to know. Thank you very much. 22:17 [outro music] Thank you again to Dan Raju for sharing your insights on meme stocks, and thank you to everyone for listening to today's discussion. We'll be back next week for another episode of Early Bird. 22:33 Have a great day. [outro music]