Transcript 0:00 Isn't this just crypto? No, it's not just crypto. Yes, it has aspects of crypto. It's, it is a digital secure- a digital asset. Mm. 0:09 Uh, but it's secured by a real world asset, so it's, it's much safer than any crypto investment, uh, crypto utility in- investment. 0:19 [upbeat music] On this episode of Early Bird, Mark Fidelman, Managing Director of SmartBlox. 0:27 Mark joins the podcast today to talk about investing in security tokens in 2023, including an industry outlook and the pros and cons of security tokens. 0:40 If you're an investor looking to stay on top of the latest market trends, then you're listening to the right podcast. This is Early Bird, and I'm your host, Steven Lerner. 0:51 Before we get to today's discussion, let me tell you how you can save time and beat the market through Early Bird, a free daily email newsletter featuring commentary about the latest trends in stocks, cryptocurrency, and equity crowdfunding. 1:07 Early Bird is designed to help individual and non-professional investors stay on top of all of the critical investing trends. The newsletter is 100% free and is sent to your email box each weekday morning. 1:21 Subscribe to Early Bird for free at www.earlybird.email. Once again, that's earlybird.email. And now, today's discussion. All right, Mark, welcome to the Early Bird Podcast. How are you doing? 1:39 I'm doing well. Thank you for having me. Well, thank you for joining us. We're talking about security tokens and what investors in 2023 should know about security tokens. 1:48 But before we do that, Mark, um, in about 30 seconds or less- Okay... what, what should the audience know about you and your background? All right, 30 seconds. Uh, primarily been in marketing my whole career. 2:02 Uh, then, uh, I'm, I'm still in marketing now, have went in, then went into crypto. Mm-hmm. So we're talking about regular crypto tokens, Bitcoin, Ethereum, all the ones that are called utility tokens. 2:13 Now seeing the writing on the walls with what's happening with the SEC and regulations, now I've moved completely into security tokens, which we're gonna talk about in a second. Yes. 2:24 So I, uh, th- this might be a great place to actually start with that. Um, most people may not be aware about what security tokens are. How would you define what security tokens are? 2:35 Yeah, I mean, everyone knows about buying stocks. Uh, well, security tokens are as safe as stocks. They're traded on different exchanges than crypto, but they represent something of value. 2:48 And why I like them better than stocks is just say you buy a stock, you know, m- Apple shares, shares of Apple. Well, you're not getting dividends, you're not getting distributions. 2:56 It doesn't get you into a, you know, a, a free Apple event. With security tokens, all of that, like crypto, can be programmed into it. So not only do you own a share of a company that's gone public via- Mm-hmm... 3:10 security tokens, but you might also own their cash flow, so you get a monthly check. You might also own, uh, a ticket to some event that they have. I mean, the sky's the limit. Yeah. 3:20 You could, they could literally program anything into it. So- So that's the difference between a security token- But, but-... and crypto... got it. But, I, I mean, you mentioned Apple. 3:28 Apple, I think, does have a dividend, like, uh, m- most stocks. Not most stocks, but a lot of stocks have dividends, um, you know, and such. And not, a- a- it, right? Just, just to clarify that. 3:39 Some stocks have dividends. I was not aware Apple did. I thought Apple did. Maybe I'm very wrong. I think, I think they do. 3:44 I could look it up real quick, but, uh, um, uh, so security tokens, give me a little bit of a history. How long have these been around? Are they fairly new? 3:52 I know crypto as, uh, as a whole is still r- really new, but i- i- in terms of crypto tokens, how far back ha- or d- have they gone in terms of their existence? Yeah. 4:02 Let's all remember that all crypto tokens are, or security tokens are, are 4:07 SEC approved instruments, meaning it's just the underlying, uh, instrument is a Reg D offering, a Reg A offering, or a Reg S offering, or a combination of them. Mm-hmm. 4:19 So these are s- the same documents that companies raise private funding from. The only difference is now they're tradable. 4:28 So imagine you as a VC investing in companies that you like, um, either they pay cash flow or other things, uh, or it's just a, represents a, a share or something of value within that company. So that- Mm-hmm... 4:42 so that, that's what they actually are. So just to, uh, um, go back for a second, Apple does have a dividend. I checked, [laughs] uh, wanted to get that right. 4:52 So it's really interesting about security tokens that you, you're saying unlike traditional crypto, it's, it's, it's, it's backed by something. 4:59 Is that really the big thing that distinguishes security tokens from Bitcoin or Ethereum or any of the other, uh, digital assets out there in cryptocurrency? That's exactly right. Um, it's backed by something of value. 5:11 So it could be a piece of art, uh, which I wouldn't recommend your audience invest in. [laughs] It could be a company, it could be a debt instrument, it could be real estate. Oh, wow. 5:21 Um, but it is something of value that you could trace back to and say, "Okay, this is why this, this token is worth X amount." So, you know, very similar to what you do with, with, with stocks. 5:32 So- But, uh, you, you could get a lot more creative with it. So, uh, do you have any examples, um, uh, that exist today? 5:38 I, I, I mean, we're not gonna talk about art, obviously, but as you said, they are backed by other things. What, what, what are some examples of security tokens out there? Yeah. 5:47 There's, uh, the, the two big ones I like to cite, there's a, a major project, it's the Ritz Carlton, uh, that was totally, they raised money via a security token offering. 5:57 So w- what that means is they issued these security tokens, you could invest in it with as little as, I think it was, uh, $500. Mm. Um, you could not do that in the real world. 6:08 No way would Ritz Carlton allow you to invest in a project they have using only $500. They're, they're looking for people with 30, 40 million. But they, they did open it up. 6:18 It's being built now.Uh, and you will get a, a share of the hotel revenue, and you will get a share of, um, any liquidity events that happen with that particular hotel. And of course, it's tradable. 6:31 Uh, and I think they even threw in a few, uh, night stays if, if, if I remember correctly. 6:35 [laughs] Uh, another example, another example is something called TurnCoin, and TurnCoin, um, takes, um, their funds, and they invest it in projects, uh, and they give off cashflow, 100% of the cashflow to the projects they invest in that produce cashflow. 6:55 So it's like a fund to funds almost, but using a security token to do that, and they're just giving back all of the profits to people that own a TurnCoin. 7:04 So you can go to INX Market Exchange right now, uh, a- and buy that, and, and when they produce income, you're gonna get it. Oh, wow. 7:13 It's, it's such a great way to sort of mix the real world with these digital virtual coins, uh, you know, tokens. Um, Mark, what, what are the benefits, the advantages for investing in security tokens? 7:27 There's, there's no shortage of investing options for, uh, the average investor today, but wh- why security tokens? What, what, what's the benefit? 7:37 Well, there's a, there's a lot of companies that are out there extremely profitable that you can't invest in because they're not big enough to go public, or it's very expensive to go public. 7:45 I mean, there's a myriad of reasons why you can't invest in these things. I mean, let's take SpaceX, for example. It's, it's an extreme one, I know. Mm. 7:53 Elon doesn't have any plans to bring it public, but what if they had security tokens where you could participate in, in what they're doing? 8:00 Uh, and there's, there's literally hundreds of thousands of companies, and I'm just talking about companies. Let's go to real estate. 8:06 You cannot, as a regular investor, invest in commercial s- real estate unless you've got millions of dollars. Well, they- They, they're just not gonna waste their time with you... 8:14 they do have platforms where you can invest in private REITs, and then there's of course public REITs as well. So there are options. REITs, yes. Right. But not, REITs aren't one project, right? 8:23 REITs are, um, like a, a real estate mutual fund. Mm. So, so you know what? You have less control over it. 8:31 With a security token, they could literally program things into that security token to offer you benefits that a stock couldn't. It's... I'm, I'm sure there's a real estate project out there that's just a single stock. 8:41 I, I... You know, like the Green Bay Packers. Mm. Um, but a security token can offer all sorts of benefits that you can imagine, uh, for the people that hold that security token. Wow. 8:53 Uh, so th- that really makes a big difference as, as you've stated with these security tokens. Um, Mark, you know, in the past year, over a year, most equities have, have been awful. Their price is down. 9:06 Cryptocurrency's price is down. How have security tokens performed in the past year? Well, the market is relatively new. Um, and when you say perform, a lot of times they're giving off income. Mm. 9:21 So it's, it's not something that's tr- it's gonna, uh, have a lot of vol- volatility. You're, you're buying it for almost like a VC. You're buying it for expected future return or the cashflow itself. 9:33 So appreciation in security tokens is gonna be very low, uh, but it doesn't go down, uh, very fast either. 9:42 It operates more like a, uh, a low beta stock than it does, um, you know, something that's, uh, like, like crypto that could go up and down 30% a day. 9:56 I've never seen that with a security token unless they have an upcoming, uh, liquidity event. Oh. So it, it's rare, though. It, it... You're saying the price is stable compared to most other investments? Very stable. 10:07 It, it's almost like- Yeah. There's not- Sorry. I was gonna say it's almost like a bond. It acts more like a bond right now, and there's not a lot of people participating yet. 10:16 But, uh, I will, I will assure you that the real world asset, the tokenization of real world assets is gonna become a big thing in two to five years. [upbeat music] Interesting. 10:34 When we return, we'll hear from Mark about why investors should consider security tokens in 2023, and his advice for new investors. 10:46 But first, let me tell you where you can become a more informed investor through Early Bird, our free daily email newsletter. 10:54 Early Bird has commentary on the latest events and trends in stocks, cryptocurrency, and crowdfunding. With Early Bird's daily weekday email, investors can quickly stay on top of the trends and beat the market. 11:08 Subscribe to Early Bird for free at www.earlybird.email. Once again, that's earlybird.email. And now back to today's discussion. 11:22 Uh, so, uh, Mark, today we are talking about the rise of security tokens, why investors should look at them in 2023. We talked a lot about the advantages of security tokens. 11:33 I wanted to focus on the disadvantages right now. What, what are some of the negatives- Yeah... associated with security tokens? 11:39 Well, right now, because there's not a lot of people investing in them, the liquidity is low. Mm. Uh, so that's one big thing. Uh, that's probably the main, uh, negative thing about them. 11:50 The second thing is if you're offering a security token, you still have to do the groundwork to find the initial security token holders. Mm. 11:59 So there's, there's a disadvantage in that because if you're investing in a real estate project, you ve- pretty much know how to invest in a real estate project, but when you add the element of a security token to it, there's a big education that needs to happen with most of these investors, even though it's better for them because they have a tradable asset. 12:18 Whereas w- if you invest in, in most real estate-Uh, projects. I'm not talking REITs. You have to wait until a liquidity event before you get your money out of it. Mm-hmm. 12:27 Uh, so that's, that's the second, uh, I think negativity. 12:31 Third, I'd say it's, it's not that high on the list, but there is some uncertainty around regulation of security tokens, because it's far easier to issue a security token, you can do so in three to six months, than it is to take a company public with all the paperwork and all that kind of stuff. 12:49 There might be, uh, some regulation that, that appears in the next couple years or so. Uh, so it's, you know, we're, we're waiting and seeing. But it is already regulated by the SEC. 13:01 Um, but the security token part of it, and the exchange of that around the world, who knows, they might decide to jump in, in, and start regulating that as well. 13:11 So you're saying regulations in other jurisdictions, other countries? Other countries, and in the US. You know, because there's not, if you look at a Reg D and a Reg A- Mm-hmm... 13:21 uh, they, there's no specific provision for trading these securities in a secondary market. 13:28 We've added it to ours because, uh, we feel it is legal, our attorneys feel it's legal, and, you know, these security tokens have been around for a while now, for the last four or five years, and the SEC hasn't sent a single letter to anybody, unlike what's happening in, in the crypto world. 13:43 Mm. Because they've, we follow the process. Uh, so but, you know, they, they might. Because it, uh, once the rest of the world figures out it's far easier to issue a security token than it is a stock or a bond, 13:55 they, uh, you know, who knows, who knows what'll happen. So there's slight risk there. So we talk about the, you know, the rise of security tokens. 14:01 Ha- have there been more investors, more buyers of security tokens i- last year than the year before that? Is it, is it still increasing in its popularity? Yes, about 83% a year it's increasing. 14:13 And, and we expect that to move up dramatically as crypto itself, uh, the utility token side of crypto gets regulated. So wh- why 2023 for security tokens? There, there's no shortage of investing options out there. 14:26 If you wanna buy a stock, buy a stock. If you want bonds, buy bonds. You want actual crypto, buy crypto, like Bitcoin. If you wanna invest in equity crowdfunding in a startup, you can do that. 14:36 You can buy REITs, you can buy artwork, you can buy alcohol, you can buy jewelry, anything, gold. But why security tokens in 2023? Yep, great question. 14:46 Because you typically can't get access to these single projects that are out there, or companies, and the token itself is tradable. Mm. So, yes, you can find pre-IPO eq- equity. 14:58 You gotta be careful with that, because there's a lot of charlatans out there. Yes, you can. But you can't trade that equity. You, you have to wait until that, uh, company IPOs. 15:07 You know, I, I, I, uh, I've seen many people that are still waiting for that IPO that need cash flow because of this economy, that can't trade that, uh, uh, that, uh, that equity around. 15:19 Uh, there just isn't a, a strong mar- secondary market for it. 15:22 Um, and then the advantages of security tokens with smart contracts, meaning you could program in all sorts of fun activities, or fun things, or benefits, or discounts, uh, into the token itself. 15:37 And so you bring your phone to, you know, if Nordstrom's issued a security token, you bring your phone into Nordstrom's and it's giving you 20% off of everything because you own a security token from Nordstrom's. 15:47 Again, I'm making this up. [laughs] Uh, it, it, it's, it's unlimited. So you'll see a lot of creativity around these security tokens, just like we've seen with NFTs. Mm. And, uh, it's gonna get interesting really fast. 15:59 Yeah. 15:59 I, I, I just wonder, though, are you concerned, security tokens, as you say, adoption is going up, but are you concerned that there might be a little bit of stigma associated with crypto right now, with NFTs, especially after the past year? 16:11 Uh, not to mention, not, not only the price, but all the scandals, the FTXs, and all the issues we've seen in crypto. Are you concerned that security tokens might see a, a dip in its popularity? 16:23 Well, Steve, you bring up the best point. [laughs] Of course. I'm constantly have to fight that battle of perception that isn't this just crypto. No, it's not just crypto. Yes, it has aspects of crypto. 16:35 It's, it is a digital secure- a digital asset. Mm. Uh, but it's secured by a real world asset. So it, it's much safer than any crypto investment, uh, crypto utility in- investment. 16:48 But, you know, there's not a lot of people that are educated on the differences. So absolutely, it's a, it's a, a big item that we as an industry have to get over. Yeah. 16:59 I, I, I think it, it, it certainly seems like an obstacle, but one that, you know, the in- your industry can certainly get past. Um, so you're, let's say you're an investor, and you're brand new to security tokens. 17:11 What advice would you offer to those new investors who are interested in security tokens this year? Yeah. I would invest in the security token exchanges, INX, TZERO, Securitize.io. Mm. 17:26 Um, remember when the Gold Rush happened in California, uh, the people that made the most money were not the gold miners. Some of them made some money. But it was people selling the pickaxes, you know, the banks. 17:37 That's where Wells Fargo started. Mm-hmm. Uh, so you wanna be, right now it's an infrastructure play, if I were just getting into it. Um, so buy the tokens of the infrastructure. Tokens of infrastructure, you're saying? 17:51 Yeah. Like INX has their own token. Mm. INX is a big, uh, exchange. TZERO, who's owned by, um, uh, can't r- remember where. It's, uh, it's owned by a very big company. 18:04 Um, eh, those are the tokens that you wanna buy, because these are the people that are like the Coinbases, the Binances in the crypto world. These are the people where the security tokens are being traded on. Hmm. 18:16 Interesting. I, I, I think that's an interesting place to be. 18:19 And for, for investors who are new and, and, and they, they, they wanna, you know, like I said, buy security tokens, um, what type of research do you recommend that they do before they do that? 18:29 Obviously speak to a financial advisor is something I would say. But what other research would you recommend?Well, I mean, they have to issue a prospectus. 18:37 It's, it's very similar to if you were investing in a big real estate project or, or company as a, as an angel investor or VC. Mm-hmm. So do the same due diligence. 18:46 Unfortunately, another weakness in the security token industry, there aren't a lot of analysts that are covering this. Mm. You know, all sorts of stocks have analysts. 18:55 And you just don't see that in the security token industry yet, uh, so you have to do your own due diligence on whatever it is that they're offering. I see. Um, y- I know you're very bullish on security tokens, Mark. 19:08 Um, where do you see security tokens going in the next one year, the next two years, the next five years? Where, where, where do you see the future of security tokens? Yeah. Uh, you know, I don't have a crystal ball. 19:19 But I, I could tell you from what I'm seeing, uh, and absent any additional regulation, the company would be foolish to go and i- and try to go public on a stock exchange, unless they're already there. 19:33 They're much better, and you could be any size organization, to take and issue security tokens to raise funds or to reward, uh, or to give away cashflow. 19:44 Um, you know, you could, you could basically issue a token right now if you're a company and say, "We're gonna give you 50- we're gonna give the token holders 50% of our future revenue." 19:54 And if you, if you have the, the trust and you've established a business, you can get a flood of money coming in of people that just want that cashflow going forward. Mm. So I, I don't see how this doesn't take over. 20:07 It will never take over the stock exchange. We'll always have a stock exchange. But, uh, other, uh, d- other funding options or other ways of raising capital for your company, I, I see it taking over. Oh, wow. 20:21 Well, we'll see if, we'll see what ends up happening with security tokens. Uh- Yeah... 20:24 Mark, tha- thank you so much for coming on the Early Bird Podcast to discuss the rise of security tokens and what investors sh- should know about it. 20:32 Um, uh, before we wrap up the podcast, I just have one final question, and it's the most important question for today's discussion. That question, uh, for you, Mark, is if you had a DJ name, what would it be? 20:47 [laughs] A DJ name. Uh, okay. If I had a DJ name, probably something like Lord Crypto or something. [laughs] Lord Crypto? [laughs] That's original. Lord. Lord- Lord Crypto... Lord Crypto. Yeah. [laughs] Yeah. 21:00 That is original. Well, you could say Bored Crypto- Oh, bored-... but, uh, like Bored Apes. Oh, Bored Crypto. Okay. [laughs] No, I'm saying, I am saying Lord Crypto. Oh. 21:11 [laughs] But, uh, uh, I, I c- I could've gone Bored Crypto like Bored Apes. Yes. [laughs] But no, Lord Crypto, I guess. Uh, you got me, you got me on that one. I, I didn't have an answer. 21:23 [outro music] Thank you again to Mark Fidelman for sharing your insights on security tokens, and thank you to everyone for listening to today's discussion. We'll be back next week for another episode of Early Bird. 21:38 Have a great day. [outro music]