Transcript 0:00 What quantitative investing would suggest, would tell you is at some point when those fundamentals get too high, you gotta stop buying the stock because it can't be a great investment moving forward. 0:11 It may still be a great company making amazing products. Doesn't make it a great investment. [upbeat music] On this episode of Early Bird, Stuart Cruise, founder and president of Cruise Asset Management. 0:28 Stuart joins the podcast today to talk about quantitative investing and quantitative asset management in 2023, including the advantages and disadvantages. 0:39 If you're an investor looking to stay on top of the latest market trends, then you're listening to the right podcast. This is Early Bird, and I'm your host, Steven Lerner. 0:50 Before we get to today's discussion, let me tell you how you can save time and beat the market through Early Bird, a free daily email newsletter featuring commentary about the latest trends in stocks, cryptocurrency, and equity crowdfunding. 1:06 Early Bird is designed to help individual and non-professional investors stay on top of all of the critical investing trends. The newsletter is 100% free and is sent to your email box each weekday morning. 1:20 Subscribe to Early Bird for free at www.earlybird.email. Once again, that's earlybird.email. And now today's discussion. All right, Stuart, welcome to the Early Bird Podcast. How are you doing? 1:38 I'm doing fantastic. Thanks for having me. Well, thank you so much for coming on. I'm excited today. 1:43 We're t- gonna talk about quantitative asset management and how investors could use it when picking different stocks in the stock market. But before we get to that, Stuart, what, what should the audience know about you? 1:54 Um, if you could in 30 seconds or less, uh, what, what, what parts of your biography do you think, uh, the audience should know about you and your background? 2:03 Well, if we're talking about quantitative investing [laughs] you know, I do have a deep numbers background. 2:07 So I have a chemistry degree, chemical engineering degree from Northwestern, a MBA in, um, finance and in game theory from Kellogg, and, um, just an all around kinda numbers guy. 2:17 But outside that, I like to play a lot of beach volleyball. I have four kids, and I've jumped out of over 100 airplanes. Nice. [laughs] Th- those are great hobbies to do, especially in the work that- Yeah. 2:28 Y- yeah, especially in the work that you're involved with, uh, at, at, at, at your company. Um, quantitative asset management, um, that's the topic we're talking about today, Stuart. 2:37 Uh, what, what's a good definition for quantitative asset management? Yeah, I would... The way I define it is using numbers- Mm... 2:45 statistics, and math to make investment decisions, and I think most people's concept are that in the financial world, most financial professionals do that. 2:56 And to some extent they obviously use some numbers, but they don't make their decisions based off of the math and statistics generally, not even the high-end portfolio managers. 3:07 So that's what we do at Cruise Asset Management. All of our stocks, all of our sectors, all of our countries, all of the models that we build are all built based off of math and statistics. 3:18 And if you ask me why I made a trade that I did, if I were, let's say buy or sell Apple stock, uh, there's a mathematical reason behind it, not just, well, their earnings came out, or they're releasing a product and I felt like it was a good time to do this, or, you know, it's off 20% off of its high, so it seems like it's at a bargain. 3:37 That's using math, kind of, but we use it all the way. So we'll, we'll use, we'll use criteria of what tends to put the odds in your favor. So it's a little bit like I, the analogy I use is going to Las Vegas. 3:53 So when I walk into Las Vegas and I play in the casinos, I'm gambling because the odds are against me, and if I play enough hands with the odds against me, I'm gonna lose money. 4:02 But the house, even though it doesn't win every hand, if it plays enough with the odds on its side, which it is, it's a mathematical certainty that they're going to win. So that's what we try to do for our investors. 4:14 We use statistics to make investment choices where the math is on their side. So you play enough hands like that, then you should outperform the market over time. Got it. 4:23 So s- essentially you're talking about using math to pick the best stocks in the market. Um, so i- i- are we talking more fundamental analysis, technical analysis? How would you sort of peg that? 4:35 Yeah, it's a little bit of both, and a- actually you have to use both, right? So longer term, the market generally reverts to fundamentals and that's like, what's the valuation of the company? 4:45 Um, you know, a- are they, are th- do they have too much debt? Are they using their assets efficiently? 4:51 But shorter term, it generally trades off of technicals, which is market momentum, relative strength, and all the algorithms. Uh, uh, two-thirds of the market is traded off of computer algorithms, if not more these days. 5:05 And so those are all technicals and not, mostly non-fundamental characteristics. So if you ignore that side, you're gonna, probably gonna get run over. So you need to look at both of them. Absolutely. 5:17 I, I can see why it's, it's part of the big picture. Um, so let's say you're a retail trader, a novice trader, and you're interested in using a quantitative asset management as a strategy for picking the best stocks. 5:29 W- what are the benefits, uh, as, as a retail trader of using this strategy? Yeah. I th- I think the benefits are massive. 5:37 So the, what the research says for a retail trader, and this is why so many day traders go out of business, and the, the numbers say more than 80% or 90% of day traders go out of business in the first year. 5:48 But even retail investors, they tend to underperform inflation. 5:53 So what that means is over time they actually erode their own purchasing power, and mostly that's because of people's biases.So they, they have confirmation bias. Hey, I have a concept. 6:05 I think I'm going to be looking for information about why this theory I have is correct, and I'm gonna jump into it. 6:12 But if you use quantitative strategies, there, there are no biases, or at least you dramatically reduce your biases. I mean, there's obviously biases when you're trying to implement particular strategies and what you... 6:23 when and when you choose to do them. But if you're using a systematic approach, it really eliminates a lot of your biases, and it helps you make better decisions. 6:33 And in fact, this easy example is, you know, this last year, or well, two years before that, a lot of people were involved in tech, and I've lived through this before in the dot-com, where people just wanna buy the Apples of the world, and Nvidias, and Salesforce, and all the ones that are trade-- moving up. 6:49 But they don't look at the rest of the market because they think tech is the only place to be, and it just... 6:55 And then when tech crashes, they're a little bit at a loss, and they just are hoping that it's gonna come back. 7:02 But hope is not a strategy, and the math would say that when a sector crashes or causes the market to go into a bear market, it, it basically has never let out of the bear market. 7:14 So s- technology brought the market down in this particular case. 7:18 Still, people I find, retail traders are finding that they, they think tech is gonna lead back out, and they wanna buy Amazon and Apple and Microsoft at these depressed prices. 7:27 But the multiples are still high, and if they're not looking at the overall market, which a systematic, um, you know, quantitative strategy will do, then they're short-changing themselves, and they're probably gonna underperform long term. 7:41 Oh, wow. I, I see what you're talking about there. It, it couldn't be detrimental if you don't follow something like this. Certainly, the benefits of, uh, quantitative asset management. 7:50 You like-- As you said, it does reduce, reduce some of those biases and errors you might find. Yeah. Um, you can also test ahead of time before you start trading, right? 7:59 And, and it can definitely be used, um, to save time in the trading process it sounds like, something that investors could really benefit from. 8:07 Um, but there are some drawbacks as well, uh, with quantitative asset management as there are with any sh- uh, strategy for investors. Yeah. What, what, what are some of the disadvantages of this strategy? 8:19 Well, uh, as you pointed out, nothing works all the time, right? 8:22 So if I have a quantitative strategy, and let's say the market is, uh, maybe this is unfair, unfairly biased phrasing from, for me, but if I, if the market is going into a period of irrationality- Mm-hmm... 8:35 like during the dot-com craze or even post-COVID when the Fed added six trillion dollars to the economy to, to prop up the economy, money had to flow somewhere. 8:46 And, um, in some cases when, when things are in disjointedness, the, it doesn't, the market doesn't act as it typically would. 8:56 So then your quantitative analysis is based off of kind of a normal market, and if that normal market isn't really in existence or in, in that moment operating the way your quantitative analysis kind of would expect it, you're probably gonna underp- underperform in that case. 9:13 So like for COVID, um, just an easy example, Apple stock, which is an amazing company obviously- Mm-hmm... 9:21 traded, pre-COVID traded at a P/E ratio, which is price to earnings, meaning what's the price and how much earnings did Apple have? 9:29 And that P/E ratio, um, is really can be thought of as how much is an investor willing to pay for a dollar of earnings? So that's a way to compare companies across different sectors and segments and times. 9:41 So, um, you know, one company might make a dollar in earnings, and one company might make forty dollars, and one company might make two dollars or twelve cents. 9:49 But you don't really know whether the company making forty dollars is worth more than the company making twelve cents unless you look at the ratio. You don't underst- The, the ratio causes the valuation. 10:00 So the P/E ratio for Apple was fifteen for like ten years pre-COVID, so still an amazing company, was still doing, crushing it, still the one of the best companies on the planet, and then w- the, the stimulus came in. 10:15 Mm. It traded up to a P/E ratio over forty. Mm. Apple wasn't growing any faster, didn't launch any new products, didn't do anything outside of just be the benefactor of all that stimulus. 10:29 Um, and what quantitative investing would suggest, would tell you is at some point when those fundamentals get too high, you gotta stop buying the stock because it can't be a great investment moving forward. 10:42 It may still be a great company making amazing products. Doesn't make it a great investment, and people are still stuck on this with Apple. 10:50 Now, again, I love Apple as a company, but even now it's trading at a P/E of over twenty, probably like twenty, twenty-five-ish. So arguably, it's still really expensive. 11:02 Um, but people still say, "Hey, it's a, at a bargain." But I, you know, the quantitative numbers would not say it is at a bargain. [upbeat music] Good point. 11:16 When we return, we'll hear from Stuart about mistakes that investors are making today and his outlook for the market's potential decline and rise in twenty twenty-three. But first, a word from our sponsor. 11:36 Let's be honest, networking for professionals is a pain in the ass, and the few options available are full of spam and people wanting to connect with you just to sell you something. 11:50 So a group of creatives launched a solution for this. It's On Meet, a new social network that allows users to connect with you only if they buy you a coffee first as a way to show their real interest. 12:06 And after the coffee is accepted-A chat unlocks and you can redeem your own drink at Starbucks. It's that simple. 12:16 ItsOnMeet users absolutely love this networking platform because it provides a way to find mentors, connections, and even job opportunities just by doing a nice thing like sending a coffee. 12:30 So if you're tired of the spam and the unwanted connections, check out ItsOnMeet. Go to itsonmeet.com and download the app for iOS or Android. ItsOnMeet. 12:47 They'll meet you for a drink. And now back to today's discussion. So, uh, Stuart, today we're talking about quantitative asset management. 13:01 Uh, you mentioned just earlier about Apple as an example, how some investors are making mistakes with their investing strategies. Some of them may not be using quantitative asset management. 13:12 Um, I'm curious, among retail traders and retail investors, what mistakes have you seen that cohort make over the past year or two with regards to investing? Oh, yeah. 13:22 Well, I mentioned s- I mentioned one of them where they just tend to be myopic, right? They, they get i-- Most people get it in their head that this is the sector, or these are the stocks, or these are... 13:32 They, they get emotional about a particular stock. And quanti- [laughs] you know, quantitative. The stock's not gonna be emotional about you. Like, it doesn't care whether you own it or not. 13:41 [laughs] It doesn't care where you bought it at or not. Doesn't care that you had a loss in it or not. So if I bought a particular company and I have a loss, and then you bought it and you have a gain in it, 13:52 what tends to happen is, with a retail investor, they tend to hold onto the company with the loss because I can't sell it and lock in that loss. And then you might sell it because you're at a gain. But 14:06 that's just our own path. What-- where our path was has no bearing on where the Apple stock is gonna go from that point in time. 14:14 And you and I are making different decisions based off of our own path and the losses, and it really is somewhat... It's overweighted in people's decision-making. 14:24 So, um, that's where quant comes in, and those are some of the mistakes people make. They just kinda let their own biases, um, take hold. People will also... Again, this is all research. Mm-hmm. 14:34 This is not me saying this. Research will say that generally people kind of remember their winners and forget their losers. Mm. 14:42 And so when they look at their own strategy like, "Oh, I'm doing awesome because I own Netflix and Apple, and I did all these great things," and then when they drop, kind of in their head they have this c-convenient amnesia where they're like, "Well, you know, it just dropped for this short period of time." 14:58 But when you look at how they actually performed and you do an analysis, they-- most retail traders do a lot worse than they think they did because they're remembering what-- when they did well. It's just human nature. 15:12 Yeah. So that's why when you use math to, like, really take a scorecard, um, it helps you really evaluate whether your strategy's working or not. Yeah. Sometimes you just gotta take a loss when you're investing. 15:23 It, it's not the end of the world. Um- No. [laughs] And so u- using math, using quantitative asset management, um, can be one of those ways to, to help with that, for sure. 15:34 Um, so, uh, Stuart, you know, we look at the, we look at the market here in twenty twenty-three. Um, there are a lot of fears of a potential recession this year. 15:43 Um, in-- Last year in twenty twenty-two, stocks did not perform well. Most stocks were down. Uh, how might the quantitative asset management strategy, um, be used in a market that we have here in twenty twenty-three? 15:58 Yeah. I mean, it-- Quite frankly, it saved our clients a ton of money in twenty twenty-two. Um, you know, I'm not saying we were positive, because that just wasn't the case. 16:07 But in early January of last year, just about this same time, we do a, um, market outlook, and our market outlook at the time made a fundamental call and it said, "When the mar-markets were at these multiples in the history of the stock market, it had never had good forward five-year returns." 16:24 It had never happened. Now, that certainly doesn't mean it can't happen, because the stock market has proven over and over again that it can do something it has never done before. 16:33 But again, we're trying to invest with the odds on our side. So to bet on something that is very unlikely is not in line with quantitative investing. So we really reduced our equity. 16:44 Now, we didn't go to zero on our equity, because we just didn't know. But we did place a big bet and reduced probably fifty percent of our equity exposure for our clients across the board- Nice... 16:53 in early January of last year. Um, because their options were either we were going to get roughly no return or a slight return, and you were gonna get volatility, or you were gonna get a decline. 17:06 Neither one was particularly a good option for us, and so we got out of equities at the time. Now, quant, just a, just a very high-level quant, um, strategy, we look at the P/E ratios. Again, I'm gonna go back to this. 17:22 We use many more metrics besides P/E. But the P/E ratios of the market were in the twenties, and inflation was basically at one percent. 17:29 And if you have those two added together, the-- if that number is over twenty, then the market tends to be kind of expensive. 17:36 And so with a P/E ratio of around twenty-one, twenty-two, and inflation around one, it was clearly an expensive market. Mm. 17:43 Today, the market has come off about twenty percent from there, so the P/E ratio's around seventeen. Still expensive from a long-term standpoint, which the average P/E ratio's around fifteen or sixteen. 17:55 So still expensive. But the inflation rate is now at seven. So the math, the quant side, would suggest we might be even more expensive today than we were back in January. 18:08 So we are not adding-To our equity exposure anytime soon. There, there is a good possibility that you could see another twenty percent decline. 18:17 Now, again, this is a little bit of art and a little bit less quant, but when you look at... couple things, you look at the average drawdown of recessions. Mm-hmm. 18:27 And they tend to last more than five hundred days, and it tends to be a drawdown of about thirty-nine and a half percent. And we're about, you know, three hundred and fifty days in- Mm-hmm... and about twenty percent in. 18:39 So we got about another three months, so maybe another fifteen percent down. Now, again, looking at the math, usually the stock market or the S&P bottoms out about three months before the economy does. 18:54 So if you're thinking a recession, and the math would suggest a recession's coming in in about six months, that means in about three months you should see a bottoming of the S&P. 19:03 So to get away from the technical, uh, from the fundamentals and move into the technicals, what we have seen, a technical indicator are all throughout 2022, higher... I'm sorry, lower highs- Yeah... and lower lows. 19:17 It's just a very fundamental technical term. Whenever you see a pattern of just lower lows and lower highs, the, the quants or the algorithms tend to trade off of that. 19:27 When they hit to a particular channel of that lower high, then they start to sell, and the selling creates more supply, and that supply creates lower prices, and those lower prices create a drop and create more selling. 19:40 So when the algorithm starts selling into this, it tends to be a little self-fulfilling until they get to the bottom of that channel and then form a lower low, and then maybe they start buying it temporarily. Mm-hmm. 19:53 So what we think the numbers say is that we're gonna go through and retest the last lows that we saw, 20:00 um, and we believe that the next set of lows will be the last set in this, um, downturn, and that we should have a, a reasonable swing up after that. And that should take us to below fair value in the market. 20:14 W- 'cause normally when you, again, you look at history, you don't go from expensive to fair value, you go from expensive to cheap. Hmm. You, you don't just stop at, "Oh, we're good, fair value." 20:23 You usually get to cheap. Mm-hmm. When people say, "Okay, now we have to start buying." Um, so that normally happens. Mm-hmm. And then, um, so that should happen in the first, first quarter, early second quarter. 20:35 Well, [laughs] we'll keep an eye out for that, huh? Hopefully the bottom is- Right... well, hopefully it's right around the corner. But we'll, we'll, we'll see though. [laughs] Yeah. 20:43 Um, Stewart, thank you so much for coming on the Early Bird Podcast discussing, you know, quantitative investing and quantitative asset management, how investors could use it. I think it's incredibly informative. 20:54 Um, before we wrap up the show, I just have one final question, and it's the most important question for today's discussion. Um, that question- Okay... 21:03 for you, Stewart, is, if you could be fluent in another language right now, which would you choose and why? Uh, [laughs] that's, it's funny you ask me that. So it's a little bit unfair. 21:15 So, uh, um, I've been married, uh, coming up on, I don't know, 17 years I think. We have four kids. My wife was born in Iran. She immigrated to Canada when she was 11. 21:26 She went to Michigan Law School, and then I met her in Chicago. But she speaks fluent Farsi. Mm-hmm. Um, as does the rest of her family. So if I could just snap my fingers, that would be the language for me. 21:37 [outro music] Thank you again to Stewart Cruz for sharing your insights on investing. And thank you to everyone for listening to today's discussion. 21:52 We'll be back next week for another episode of Early Bird. Have a great day. [outro music]