Transcript 0:00 It is difficult to see how piling into Netflix now as a severely beaten down stock makes sense because though it is very badly beaten down, it was falling from a height that was unjustifiable on any, like, economic ground. 0:18 [on-hold music] On this episode of Early Bird, John Engel, president of Almington Capital Merchant Bankers. 0:28 John joins the podcast today to talk about the streaming wars in the stock market with Netflix and other competitors, including a look at the recent earnings from Netflix. 0:39 If you're an investor looking to stay on top of the latest market trends, then you're listening to the right podcast. This is Early Bird, and I'm your host, Steven Lerner. 0:49 Before we get to today's discussion, let me tell you where you can save time and beat the market through Early Bird, our free daily email newsletter featuring commentary about the latest trends in stocks, cryptocurrency, and equity crowdfunding. 1:05 Early Bird is designed to help individual and non-professional investors stay on top of all of the critical investing trends. The newsletter is one hundred percent free and is sent to your email box each weekday morning. 1:19 Subscribe to Early Bird for free at www.earlybird.email. Once again, that's earlybird.email. And now, today's discussion. 1:32 All right, John, thank you for coming today to the Early Bird podcast. Welcome, John. How are you doing? I'm doing great. Like, thanks for having me on. No problem. I'm really excited. 1:44 Uh, today we're going to be talking about Netflix stock a-and really all the other stocks in this streaming space and what it means for retail investors. 1:52 Uh, before we do that, though, let's, uh, talk a little bit about your background, John. Um, if you could, thirty seconds, quick biography. Tell everybody quickly about your background. Sure. My name is John Engel. 2:04 Uh, I am president of Almington Capital Merchant Bankers. Uh, we are s-small investment firm based in Illinois. 2:11 Uh, my background is in startup financing as-- and consulting as well as in, uh, venture capital and public equities investments. 2:21 And, uh, our firm specializes in sort of special eve- uh, special situations and event-driven investing across a univer- a, a wide universe of different industries. Nice. So you're well diverse. That's great. 2:34 Uh, have lots of different opportunities for your firm. Um, so, so today we're talking about Netflix. 2:40 Um, just a few weeks ago, Netflix, the streaming giant, posted its earnings, and the earnings did not go so well for the company. The company, uh, lost two hundred thousand subscribers. 2:51 It marked the first time in over ten years that Netflix actually lost subscribers in a quarter. A-and the company expects to lose even more subscribers i-in the upcoming quarter, the one that we're currently in. 3:03 Um, John, what do you make of Netflix post-earnings? 3:08 Well, uh, as is often the case with companies that are driven very heavily by a, a narrative expectation of essentially infinite growth- Mm-hmm...uh, when that growth hits a wall, even a mo- even a moderate one, it can completely alter, ch-- uh, can transform the way people, uh, look at that stock. 3:27 Netflix is a perfect example of that. 3:29 The, uh-- And doubly so, because not only is it a highly narrative-driven stock in its own right, it is also, until very recently, uh, in terms of public mind share and investor mind share, been treated as if it r- as if it is the streaming industry and that it's almost a proxy for streaming as a whole. 3:49 As competitors have emerged and now as Netflix's growth has stalled fundamentally, that que- that view is being, has been radically reassessed and, and caused the, uh, pretty tremendous drop in, uh, the stock since earnings. 4:03 Yeah. I, I, I think you're right. The streaming industry has changed. Um, Netflix, you know, as we said, bad earnings for Netflix. Um, what do you make of the earnings? They, they, they, they lost subscribers. 4:14 They blamed everything from competition. They blamed the war in Europe. They blamed password sharing. What, what do you make of the actual earnings from the company? 4:23 Um, I mean, Netflix, like, as, as, as you-- as has been the case for quite a while, uh, brought-- like, had very, like, healthy revenue. 4:31 Their cost of revenue, however, is growing faster than their actual re-- than, than their revenue is growing, which is a function in large part of the fact that Netflix, unlike a lot of other streaming platforms, is reliant on licensing the content of other IP, uh, IP holders rather than, uh, re-resting on their own. 4:50 In terms of the actual, like, earnings, like, there wasn't anything catastrophic on the finan- on the financial side so far. 4:57 But, uh, Netflix has, has never made as much money as its valuation implied because the expectation has always been that as Netflix eventually sort of becomes the, the streaming universe, it would b- have enormous pricing power that would eventually allow it to raise prices and sort of move from very, very thin margins s- and, uh, like, frequently negative ca-- uh, overall, like, free cash flow when you're talking about reinvestment in content themselves. 5:24 Uh, you end up with, uh, a lot of problems when you-- when thing-- when content becomes more expensive, you can't grow your top line, and people are going elsewhere for, uh, like, their content. 5:37 So Netflix, they lost two hundred thousand in the first quarter. That is not, uh, the worst outcome on its own. 5:46 Uh, like, a more, uh-- T-they lost more people from leaving Russia than the two hundred thousand net loss was, so they would have still had a small net gain if they hadn't, uh, basically shut off service in Russia. 5:57 Uh, but that won't be an excuse in the next quarter, and they know that, and they've already flagged that they're going to lose, you know, an order of magnitude more, like, in the million-plus, uh, range of sub- of subscribers in the next quarter, which is obviously not great for a company that, uh, is valued as if it will grow ad infinitum.Yeah. 6:17 It, it, it's not a good time for Netflix. It, it, it sounds like you're pretty, uh, bullish on the stock, right? [laughs] Uh, I, I, I, I w- I would call myself- [laughs]... on the sidelines right now. 6:30 [laughs] It's fallen, it's fall- fallen a lot, uh, and a lot-- I'd say that it-- 6:36 but what we, what we did, what I'd say most people, uh, w- would wisely do in the near term would be like to, to cover or to watch on the sidelines or at least reduce a short position if they have one- Mm-hmm... 6:48 uh, because, uh, it's fallen a lot. 6:50 There-- it probably has more to lose over the longer run as peoples, uh, come to terms more and more with the fact that Netflix is one of many fiercely, like, uh, many- one of many competitors in a fiercely competitive and ruinously, uh, difficult market to be in, like in terms of just media. 7:08 Mm-hmm. Uh, and that they have the d- fundamental disadvantage of not having anything other than streaming. Mm-hmm. And their IP own-- the, the IP they actually own is, uh, very limited. Mm. 7:19 So I, I, I'm-- agree with you totally. I, I, [laughs] and I was being sarcastic before, I don't agree-- I'm, I'm not, uh, I'm not bullish on this company. I, I, I do not own it. 7:30 But I just wanna play devil's advocate a little bit here. Let- Okay... let's just hypothetically assume that I was bullish on the company. 7:36 Uh, the stock is down, what is it, seventy percent, more than seventy percent since peaking several months ago. Um, so it's a good buy the dip opportunity. 7:46 Um, it's a company where, uh, they're going to look at other revenue streams, including advertising revenue in the future. 7:54 And then in the immediate future, they've got the latest season of Stranger Things coming out, as well as other series. Is this-- is, is that not a good opportunity for investors as you see it, or am I missing something? 8:06 Well, I would say that there is, uh, based on just sort of the trading pa- behavior around Netflix is that n- you know, new, significant new content dropping can be a tailwind, like a positive tailwind. Mm-hmm. 8:19 Uh, the fact that it is beaten down, which is why I say, like, standing on the sidelines is probably a smart move if you were shorting it until recently, uh, simply because there, there will be traders who may think, and there m- like, to create sufficient mo- a sufficient number of traders to create sufficient momentum to pop it up a little bit. 8:37 But, uh, looking at the sort of broader trend, it is difficult to see how piling into Netflix now as a severely beaten down stock makes sense, because though it is very badly beaten down, it was falling from a high that was unjustifiable on any, like, economic grounds. 8:57 I mean, even now, Netflix's, uh, market cap, uh, you know, in the-- which in the, in sort of the eighty billion range, uh, this week, that is, uh, just a little less than half right now of what Disney's is. 9:12 And you're look-- And so if you compare those two companies- Mm-hmm... you know, Disney is rapidly gaining on Netflix in terms of will probably have as many streaming, uh, customers as Netflix does- Mm-hmm... this year. 9:23 And that, and streaming is just one of an omni-channel, uh, media empire that Disney has. Yes. [laughs] So it does, it has television, it has films, it has, uh, merchandise that is- Yes... 9:34 just incredible, incredible business. It has, uh, theme parks. Yes. It has all these, these element, these elements that are monetizable, but it also owns just an astonishing amount of monetizable IP. 9:47 Like, Stranger Things is actually a very good example of one of Netflix's very few, uh, potentially durable, uh, pieces of IP. 9:56 But even it, if you think about it, is actually basically just a derivative of [laughs] like nineteen eighties le-- uh, horror nostalgia and sort of t- teen movie nos- nostalgia. Yeah. 10:06 Like, it ha-- I'm not saying, I'm not, I'm not trying to trash talk Stranger Things. 10:10 I'm saying that it is something that is built on, on other IP, like f- and memories of other IP, is difficult to make into sort of the flagship ex- explanation for why [laughs] uh, you should believe that their IP portfolio will, uh, be able to sustain them through this. 10:27 Because it just costs an incredible amount of money and a lot of time to build a, a Disney level or even, like, Viacom or CBS, like, has all these, uh, really great, uh- Yeah... uh, IP, uh, catalogs. 10:40 I think, I think few in the world today have that kind of- So Donna, I do wanna talk about these competitors in a second. Sure. But, but I, I think it's very interesting. 10:48 Hopefully, you know, I, I don't think Netflix can wait any longer until the next Squid Games comes out. They might need that boost as soon as possible. 10:54 Um, but I, I kinda wanna take a, a, a step back a little bit quickly and just look at this higher level topic. 11:00 Um, you've said to me earlier about how retail investors have considerable exposure to the company and, and you wanted to highlight the dangers of narrative-driven stocks in rapidly ev- in evolving industries. 11:13 Can, can you explain what, what you mean by that? Right. Absolutely. 11:16 So as is, as is-- what can frequently happen when you have a new technology and new, and disruptive new player enter a market, uh, is that people begin to associate the new technology or the new business modality with that company. 11:36 So, uh, you, you've seen this a lot in re- in re- in recent years. You see, uh, like Netflix being just one example, in this case becoming essentially representative of streaming. 11:47 The people who believe that str- who believe that streaming was the future invested in Netflix because Netflix was, was streaming. Right. 11:55 We saw this play out in, uh, a much shorter timeframe with things like Virgin Galactic, which was seen as, you know, the first real, essentially pure play space flight, uh, stock, that people were investing in it because it was the one thing they could invest in that was part of the space economy. 12:10 That obviously corrected rapidly. 12:13 You see, uh, it with like electric vehicles, where Tesla, uh, for ma- for many years and even now is valued in a, at a way that almost implies that it is the, not only the electric vehicle industry, but sort of the future dominant player in automotive. 12:27 Mm. So you have this narrative that makes it very easy to think about the one player that's growing rapidly, uh, as the inevitable only player in the in- in the industry. 12:38 But unlike, uh-Sort of networking platforms, uh, such as, you know, search in the case of Google or ki- various kinds of, like, social networks that have emerged. There, uh, or Amazon with distribution. 12:51 There isn't a natural monopoly here that can be, that is, that can be defended, and media is actually one of the ones that is least defensible because, uh, creation and dissemination of, you know, monetizable intellectual property is a, is a much longer sort of development and sales cycle, but it's also just fiercely competitive, and the barriers to entry are extremely low. 13:14 [upbeat music] Streaming is a competitive market. When we return, we'll hear from John about different streaming stocks and his advice for retail investors. 13:28 But first, let me tell you where you can become a more informed investor through Early Bird, a free daily email newsletter. 13:36 Early Bird has commentary on the latest events and trends in stocks, cryptocurrency, and crowdfunding. With Early Bird's daily weekday email, investors can quickly stay on top of the trends and beat the market. 13:50 Subscribe to Early Bird for free at www.earlybird.email. Once again, that's earlybird.email. And now, back to today's discussion. 14:02 Uh, so John, today we're, we're talking about Netflix, um, and the horrible earnings it just had, but we're also taking a look at the, the, the streaming industry as a whole and some of the big up-and-coming competitors. 14:15 You've mentioned one already, Disney, and how it has this really nice, um, diversified portfolio of, of beyond just streaming. 14:23 It has the theme parks and other properties, and, and, and it's able to get revenue from different sources. Uh, what other companies that are involved in streaming that you also like? Like is a, is a, is a- [laughs]... 14:35 is a, is a diff... is a, is a difficult term in the sense that I believe that there are, there is value in some of these, uh, platforms, but frequently 14:45 you, you s-- there is a diff-- there's a difference between having a good product and a well-priced, and a well-priced business from, from a, from an investment standpoint. Got it. 14:53 [laughs] And as with much of streaming media, we've seen, like, Disney had, you know, a fairly parabolic rise, like, uh, like, o- in, uh, in, in the last couple years as people began to reprice it as a streaming company. 15:05 Mm-hmm. 15:06 But that repricing i- it can be great when you're riding it up, but when people realize that the economics will be more similar to what was, what was already known, uh, the repricing tends to go back towards that direction. 15:19 So in terms of what companies, like, I, I like amongst streaming, amongst streaming players and what platforms I think are interesting, I think Viacom has had some issues- [laughs]... like, uh, to say the least. Uh, 15:32 uh- Yes. [laughs] But it's, it's got a good- Like, I, I, I would say that it is- They've got a lot of good properties, Viacom. [laughs] It is a... 15:39 [sighs] Uh, its whole issues have, like, have made it a bit untouchable from my, from, from my, from my perspective even now. Mm-hmm. Uh, but, uh, the biggest, the only, the, the... 15:52 So the only real streaming players that I think are interesting- Mm-hmm... 15:56 as part of a bigger company are, like, are probably Disney would be the top, would be at the top, principally because they are spending a ton of money on building their streaming channel. Mm-hmm. 16:08 They are also packaging it with, uh, their s- with sports in terms of ESPN Plus, which is, uh, an, uh, an, an important thing to consider because, uh, cut, cord cutting has been an issue for Disney for a while. 16:22 But now that it is able to provide an alternative, uh, it is able to, hopefully it may be able to sustain its, like, very lucrative, uh, professional sports, uh, network subscription, uh, business. But, uh- Yeah... 16:37 all the players that are... Like, so streaming's gonna probably go, like, basically the... 16:40 And then you, and then you have other players that are, like, not true, that are also not pure play streaming players, but are also, are doing it even more tangentially- Mm-hmm... than Disney. 16:48 Like, Disney, streaming makes perfect sense because it's a, it's a content company. Yeah. It's a visual content medium, media company. 16:55 You have, uh, but then you have companies like Apple do it with Apple TV and Amazon with Prime Video, uh, both of which are producing interesting content, but, you know, they're pursuing streaming in a, in a fundamentally diff- uh, from a fundamentally different strategic mindset. 17:09 Like, neither of them are aiming to become, like, to compete with Netflix and the, or, or with Disney Plus. You know, they're not trying to be those companies. 17:18 That is just a value add on an already existing, uh, platform, especially for, from Amazon's perspective. So- Yes... 17:25 it's important to not, like, to think of, to think of what, why each company is doing streaming and whether they can do it effectively and whether the, the, the strategy that they're pursuing will make sense. 17:36 A lot of people will s- you know, a lot of investors, you know, in the narrative era would, would say, like, "Well, there's no way that Prime Video or that Apple TV will ever be able to compete with Netflix." 17:44 Point is that they're, they, they, they don't want to. That's not their, that's not what they're there to do. Yes. A- a- and there's certainly several others. 17:49 You know, you mentioned Apple and Amazon and, and the streaming platforms they have. Those are not pure play streaming companies, as you said, but there's so many others. 17:57 There's Google w- w- who own A- YouTube and YouTube TV, uh, Comcast. Mm-hmm. You know, another content powerhouse, they have the Peacock platform out there. 18:05 So, uh, we, it's, it's certainly an interesting universe of streaming companies in the market right now. 18:11 Yep, and I think that that's, it's, it's gonna be interesting to see for the companies that are, uh, media companies that are, that are s- o- one of the sort of big network owners that, you know, includes Disney, but, uh, it also includes, you know, CBS's, Root, uh, you have Peacock and NBC on, uh, on, in its, in its lane as a, uh, way to buttressThe value of, you know, the, the core networks that are still what pe- the, the only, like, the, the thing that everyone still has on their TVs if they have a TV. 18:43 Mm. A-and so I, I mean, all these companies i-are, are trying to get into streaming, um, you know, and, and, and some of them are being successful. Disney in the past few years has been succe-successful. 18:53 You know, we recently saw CNN try to release their own app- [clears throat]... and, and it failed miserably. 18:59 Um, I, I, I guess from an investor's standpoint, when you, when you see all these companies coming out with their, their new streaming apps, should, should you pause a minute a-and, and take it with a, with a grain of salt, so to speak? 19:11 Um, I would say look closely at what's going on. So like, if like, if a company announces a new... like, that it's going into, getting into streaming, f-first ask what their, like, what their actual strategy is. Mm. 19:24 'Cause if they're talking about going head-to-head with companies like, like, like Disney or Netflix that are spending, you know, $10 to $30 billion on content every year, like, if they're do- if they're g- if they think they're gonna go head-to-head with that with a sort of niche player, they're doomed. 19:39 But if they have a plan that will a-actually be able to help them monetize the existing IP or create new revenue streams for, at like a relatively low incremental cost for things they already have, that's, like, that's interesting. 19:54 Mm. And, uh, b- however, like, overall, I would [chuckles] s- uh, say that by and large, streaming's kind of saturated, and everyone knows about it, so that trying... Like, and so 20:08 there is not an enormous amount of excitement, I would say, like, and, uh, from, and, and then from an investing standpoint of companies trying to get into this market. 20:18 So with that being said, John, what advice would you offer to retail investors on this particular topic of streaming stocks? Um, I, I would 20:30 rem- I would ask that, I would s-re-recommend that they consider what the actual steady state of the future is likely to be. Like, look 10 years from now at what you... 20:41 or f- just look five years from now at where you think streaming media is going to be, uh, overall, and do you think it will be more diffuse or more consolidated? Uh, 20:53 and do you think that there's any chance that one of these companies that is current- like, that would, that's still being priced, you know, any of these companies that are priced richly on the basis of in-infinite or nigh infinite growth, it, what is the real chance of that happening? 21:06 Because the long term is made up of many sh- of, of, of many short terms, and if in the sh- and if each short term fails to meet the long, that long-term growth trajectory, 21:18 you're never gonna get to the long term you want. 21:20 So to retail investors who are, like, who are in these sort of stocks, not just streaming, but streaming's an excellent example of it, where there has been heavy narrative where they get, uh, in-inordinate amounts of coverage, not only, like, on places like CNBC as well, and, uh, on, uh, financial media and on financial websites, over-covered stocks that have become sort of totems of an industry, 21:45 rethink your exposure to those overall because your exposure to sort of idiosyncratic risk of those companies that are, 21:55 even in the best of circumstances, perhaps not going to meet their current valuation, like how, like, like they... 22:02 It is difficult to see how holding a position and hoping that it will grow into an even larger valuation may be, uh, like, wishful thinking. Mm. Good, good point there. John, one more question. 22:15 Uh, th- uh, thank you so much, by the way, for coming on the show a-and giving your insights on this very important issue. Um, I just have one more question, and it's the big question for today's discussion. 22:24 Um, that question is, um, John, during a zombie apocalypse- Mm... which fictional character would you want by your side? Any fictional character? Any. Uh, probably, like, Superman, I guess. 22:43 Why not? He can't be bitten by human teeth. I'm gonna stand behind him. [chuckles] Great answer. 22:49 [upbeat music] Thank you again to John Engel for sharing your insights on streaming stocks, and thank you to everyone for listening to today's discussion. We'll be back next week for another episode of Early Bird. 23:07 Have a great day. [upbeat music]