Transcript 0:00 That the old conventional theses about, uh, reversion to the mean or, uh, 0:07 the s- the sort of traditional fundamental analysis has to be leavened with a, like, understanding of sort of a n- the new era of, of sort of financial capital as it works now. Mm. 0:18 I think that's, like, a kind of huge lesson that is being sort of metabolized by the market. When, you know, the market's up, everything's up, you know. You can invest in anything. 0:25 Close your eyes and you're up over 20% almost. [upbeat music] On this episode of Early Bird, what are the most memorable investing themes in the stock market in 2024? 0:39 Plus, what are the most important investing lessons learned from the past year? 0:45 John Cook, senior investment analyst at iSectors, and John Engel, president of Almington Capital Merchant Bankers, join the podcast today to discuss these topics. 0:55 If you're an investor looking to stay on top of the latest market trends, then you're listening to the right podcast. This is Early Bird, and I'm your host, Steven Lerner. 1:05 Before we get to today's discussion, let me tell you how you can save time and beat the market through Early Bird, a free daily email newsletter featuring commentary about the latest trends in stocks, cryptocurrency, and equity crowdfunding. 1:19 Early Bird is designed to help individual and non-professional investors stay on top of all of the critical investing trends. The newsletter is 100% free and is sent to your email box each weekday morning. 1:33 Subscribe to Early Bird for free at www.earlybird.email. Once again, that's earlybird.email. And now, today's discussion. All right, everybody, welcome to the Early Bird Podcast. 1:50 Thank you so much for joining us. Today, we are going to take a look back at the stock market in 2024. 1:57 I'm joined by John Engel, president of Almington Capital Merchant Bankers, and John Cook, senior investment analyst at iSectors. 2:06 Thanks both of you for coming on the podcast today for this very important episode where we take a look back at the stock market in 2024. How you both doing? Great. Yeah, same. Pretty exci- uh, interesting year. 2:21 Absolutely. Um, before we get started, I, I, I actually have a very simple question. I don't know if it's that simple, but to ask both of you. I'm just looking for, for a one-word answer. 2:31 Um, if there's one word that you can say that might describe the stock market in 2024, uh, what word would, would that be? Um, John Cook, I'll start with, start with you. 2:44 Is there one word that comes to mind when you look back at the stock market in 2024? Yeah. Concentrated. That's my word. Ooh, interesting choice. 2:56 And John Engel, is there a word that comes to your mind when you look back at 2024 in the stock market? Um, I would say exuberant. Ooh. Yeah. Two int- interesting words. Um, so John Cook, let me... 3:09 l- I guess we'll start with you. Um, w- when you look back at 2024 in the stock market, um, what were some of the more memorable investing themes that come to your mind? Yeah. 3:22 So last year was a very good year for the stock market, or this year I should say. Mm-hmm. Um, up over 25% about as of right now. The year before, 2023, is up about the same as well. 3:34 And this is in the face of, um, I don't know, a lot of market participants seeming to feel squeamish, right? 3:41 We, we have the talks of inflation and high interest rates and the geopolitical problems and wars around the world. 3:48 But yet we're still up, you know, over 20% two years in a row, which is, uh, almost double the long-term average for the S&P 500 at least is about 11%. 3:57 And we're doubling that two years in a row in the midst of all this, um, you know, worry, a wall of worry, so to speak. 4:05 And so it's hard to find something that didn't really perform well over, uh, these last 12 months here. But what, like, what stands out to me, um, is when in a year where almost everything's up... 4:17 I mean, even for instance, even gold, gold was up about the same as the stock market, and that has, like, no correlation, right? So even things w- that aren't correlated to each other are going up 20, 25% in a year. 4:29 Um, what, what we've been-- had our eye on is Bitcoin. Mm. This has sort of been the year of Bitcoin. I mean, earlier this year we had the, the Bitcoin ETF launch, the spot Bitcoin ETF products launched. Mm. 4:41 And so Bitcoin's up, like, over 150% this year when, you know, the market's up, everything's up, you know. You can invest in anything, close your eyes, and you're up over 20% almost. 4:50 Um, Bitcoin gives you something that has, you know, quadrupled that return almost. 4:57 And if we're talking specific stocks, you know, MicroStrategy has earned a lot of media attention as sort of a Bitcoin holding company, so to speak. 5:06 That's up, like, as of today, you know, 400% year to date, a little more. Um, and so that-- those are kind of what we've had our eyes on and what's been really interesting, interesting to us in the markets this year, um, 5:21 th- those outsized returns of Bitcoin and, and MicroStrategy. Yeah. We- we're still standing. You're right. That is... 5:28 No matter what, uh, problems there may be in the world or in the economy, many investments did very well, both traditional equities and, um, the price of both gold and Bitcoin, as well as other cryptocurrencies jumped this year as well. 5:45 It really is remarkable to see so much resiliency in the market, especially with so many different types of, uh, um, investments. Um, John Engel, what, w- what do you think? 5:57 What, what, what are some of the big investing themes that, uh, stood out to you in the stock market this past year?Yeah, I think, uh, John, uh, uh, the other John already s-- uh, uh, pointed out something very in, uh, interesting that has been happening in the market with why I say exuberant in the sense that it-- a more or less bull market of everything that's been going on for a r-- uh, for almost a decade, but has acc-accelerated remarkably 6:24 even as there are apparent dislocations between, uh, financial assets and the real economy and certainly perceptions of the... like within the real economy. 6:36 I think, uh, John already alluded to this, uh, that, uh, the wall of worry, as he said, but also in terms of just like real world, like economic, uh, like pressures that you see, for example, like across the European Union, not only like political unrest and dislocation, but like rising energy prices, but al- uh, actual tipping into recession in many cases. 6:57 But none of these things have done much to dampen financial assets. 7:02 I would say that that market exuberance has been remarkable and indicative of a, of, uh, a fairly unprecedented like dislocation from, uh, like the underlying economy, and that th-- uh, it, but it's not as if twenty twenty-four is a unique case in that. 7:21 It's, you know, it's a, you know, one of those remarkable things that since really the COVID-19 lockdowns and the sort of remarkable levels of quantitative easing and, uh, financial asset support that happened during that period that has never... 7:38 that has not unwound, has created a, a, a sort of perpetual bull market at least f- like through twenty twenty-four as we've seen. 7:49 But as a result of that, when you start seeing that dislocation, when you're seeing, you know, price, price earnings multiples being, you know, at a, uh, w-- like significantly higher than their like thirty-five year average even, you know, like over thirty percent above that. 8:03 Where you see like the top, like the sort of, um, really enormous like mega cap stocks, uh, leading, uh, like a lot of that, a lot of this growth. 8:14 There's really a lot of like remarkable things happening like b- in the financial assets versus the real economy. 8:20 We also see like this is also, you know, demonstrable from things like fed policy, which has, uh, never really normalized since twenty-- two thousand and nine to the point where, you know, the new normal is essentially where w-- the sort of perpetual sort of easier quantitative marketplace, and where even with extremely low interest rates, like the market kinda got sh-- uh, shook, so to speak, like a little bit. 8:46 Like, uh, when, uh, uh, Chairman Powell, you know, said that he was going to... that they were going to like slow down rate cuts- Mm... 8:52 like from already like fairly historic lows that they've a- that they've been at, you know, s-since the great financial crisis. 8:59 So it is a multi-decade sort of unprecedented trend, and as the real economy sort of is dislocating more so, it's something to, uh, be paying attention to, especially as the uncertainties like in the world do not seem to be diminishing [chuckles] at the end of this year. 9:19 No, you're right. It's, it's, it's been incredible. Um, you mentioned the, uh, John Engel, I'll stay on you for a sec. You mentioned the Fed. 9:27 Um, you know, obviously we've had somewhat elevated rates compared to the past few years in twenty twenty-four, um, and yet it seems that the risky assets did very well this year, Bitcoin and the technology stocks. 9:43 Um, uh, John Engel, could you talk a bit about the technology stocks this year? Obviously many semiconductor stocks did very well, big tech did well. 9:51 Is this just, uh, a result of the AI race, or is there something larger at play here when so many, uh, riskier assets perform well, even though rates were a bit elevated throughout the year? 10:06 Uh, well, that's, like, an, an interesting way, like interesting framing. 10:08 You know, when we say rates being elevated somewhat this year, you know, they're elevated compared to like, like his-history-breaking l-lows that persisted for well over a decade. 10:21 And when the market had s-- has sort of gotten, got used to that extremely low rate that it was, you know, threw a bit of a temper tantrum when rates were still historically low, even at the highest rate that they've been raised to in like, in the tightening cycle. 10:35 Uh, 10:37 so you do see that like, that there is, in that context, like if they were to, say, restore rates to, you know, the thirty-year average, that would probably cause pretty catastrophic results like in financial markets. 10:50 So that's not gonna happen, obviously. They, they're not even talking about tightening right now. But it is indicative and important to understand that 10:59 the sort of nature of the Fed's rate policy versus financial assets is different and has been for several years, and this has really been sort of playing out in the last few years, uh, than it, than 11:12 any sort of textbook or hi-- or history would tell you like that that relationship, how that relationship exists. Mm. 11:17 In terms of like, uh, risky assets, uh, you know, when there is, uh, so much, uh, like fi-- uh, financial capital in the marketplace at an unprecedented amount and where rates are like still low overall, there is a degree at which, uh, the hunt for yield is always on. 11:35 And when you have things like debt markets like still remaining because the base rate is so low, even when it, even when it was elevated slightly, uh, the search for that yield, the search for those returns, uh, demands seeking like riskier assets. 11:50 That's why you see even, you know, hist- traditionally very conservative large pools of capital like pension funds, uh, increasingly ex-ex-- uh, like i-increasing their exposure to, uh, like high-risk assets in the search for not just, um, re-Like equity return, but also for that sort of income and yield return. 12:11 So, uh, those are all pressures that, like, naturally, over time, accel- accel- uh, accelerates the demand for those high-risk products. 12:19 Also in those cases, like large pools of capital, one of the forcing f-functions of that is an aging population. Oh, yeah. That's just the kind of the way things are. 12:28 Um, you know, I think we've mentioned so far what sectors and types of stocks have been doing well. Obviously, tech did very well. 12:36 Um, you'd, you'd, you'd be hard-pressed to find a sector that really struggled this year, but there were still a few, uh, sectors and companies that, um, lagged the broader market in twenty twenty-four. 12:47 Um, John Cooke, is there-- are there any stocks or sectors that come to your mind when you think of, oh, this sector, this company really struggled in twenty twenty-four? Anything that sticks out to you? Um, yeah. 13:04 The energy sector, absolutely. Um, a- you know, it's flat-ish, little negative so far this year. 13:13 The big, the big companies there, you know, Exxon, Chevron, they're not-- haven't been holding up any of the broader energy stock indexes, that's for sure. Um, basic materials is another. 13:25 We have a, a sector rotation model where we, um, you know, dynamically allocate to different sectors every month and- Mm-hmm...basic materials, we've had that sort of, you know, in and out position this year, and that's been another sector that really hasn't, um, been able to keep up. 13:41 More of these defensive sectors, right? 13:43 Uh, more value-oriented sectors- Mm-hmm...and that's specifically the case with energy- Mm-hmm...um, have underperformed given that sort of the appetite for risk that John Engel discussed before. 13:54 Um, it, it's just sort of-- it's left more of these defensive plays, um, by the wayside. Oh, yeah. Um, John Cooke, um, you brought up a great point. Some of these defensive sectors have struggled this year. 14:07 Um, why do you think the defensive strugg-- uh, sectors are struggling this year? Is it-- is there something about the nature of investments this year? 14:14 Are there any macro trends that might be contributing to the struggle, uh, for these defensive sectors in twenty twenty-four? 14:22 Well, I think it's partially the, the sort of risk appetite of the market John Engel touched on before. 14:29 Um, he may-- he mentioned the, the, the liquidity hasn't really been unwound from the large amounts of quantitative easing through COVID-19, and that's absolutely true. 14:39 I mean, the money supply, if you look at a money supply chart, M2 or otherwise, um, it, it blew up in-- during COVID, you know, as they pumped stimulus into the markets, and it started pulling back a little bit as the Fed was raising rates. 14:54 But then now, if, uh, if you look recently, the year-over-year money supply is increasing again. Mm-hmm. Um, so th-that-- you're not gonna get all that liquidity. 15:03 They say, you know, the toothpaste doesn't go back in the tube, as they say. [laughs] And that money's in the system, and it's just 15:09 e-especially with now the Fed cutting a little bit here, obviously the, the bond market, um, doesn't really agree with that, I don't think. 15:15 But they've begun cutting, and they, uh-- who knows if they'll actually be able to keep rates as high as they would need to, to be truly restrictive and sort of pull back some of this liquidity that's in the market right now. 15:27 Good point. Um, John Engel, are there any, um, sectors or stocks lagging the market that stand out to you in twenty twenty-four? Sure. Yeah. 15:39 Yeah, uh, I'd agree that, like, uh, defensive plays in general have, have performed poor- like, not poorly by comparison. 15:47 Uh, you know, deep values-oriented stocks, uh, uh, not as well, and then you have, like, sort of big, big name players that have just had, you know, disastrous years. 15:58 Uh, Boeing, you know, being one of the, uh, sort of poster children of the, uh, 16:04 like, mass failure of, like, certain kinds of management styles that have, uh, damaged a lot of companies in, uh, recent decades, that they're sort of unwinding a sort, uh, sort of fundamental management failure. 16:17 You know, they're down close to forty percent this year after having pretty bad years before that. Uh, but it is, uh, like sectorally definitely a fact-- uh, a function of stocks that are 16:30 seen as safer get left-- uh, have, have de- have definitely lagged those that are sort of the, uh, other, uh, sort of tail end of the bull whip. Mm-hmm. Uh, and that's to be expected in this, uh, you know, fairly, uh, 16:44 flush with liquidity, like, uh, fi- uh, financial system of the current-- at the current, uh, state of things. And as, uh, the other John said, the, uh, 16:54 uh, fact that, you know, monetary policy, uh, you know, isn't changing significantly and, uh, the sort of in-growing money supply is-- isn't changing, uh, and there is no-- uh, is-- it has to be accounted for. 17:12 And at the same time, you have to factor in the fact that no political party, not even the Fed leadership, which are, you know, theoretically apolitical, uh, seem to be willing to jump on the obvious political grenade that would happen to tr- of trying to even get near what would've con- been considered, 17:32 uh, through most of, like, the Fed's history, normal monetary policy. Yeah. The Fed plays an outsized r-role in what's happening now in the stock market, for sure. 17:42 Um, uh, you know, we're about to enter a new year, twenty twenty-five, and so as we wrap up this discussion on what happened, uh, in the stock market in twenty twenty-four, uh, were there any lessons learned from this past year that we might be able to apply in the new year, in twenty twenty-five? 18:00 Anything we learned about the market or investing that we could apply next year? Um, John, uh, Engel, I'll start with you. 18:07 Are there any lessons learned from this past year that we might be able to apply in twenty twenty-five?Um, yeah, I'd, I'd say that one big one is that, uh, in a system where US capital markets are dominant and will remain so for the foreseeable future, where the economic base of the US is still going to dominate the s- the capital market structure, there is, uh, alway-- like, almost 18:33 an unprecedented amount of room for expensive things to get more expensive and expensive stocks to get more expensive, so to speak. So the lessons of the-- of, of this year have been that, uh, 18:48 it's import-- it-- that a nor-- that the old conventional theses about, uh, reversion to the mean or, uh, the s- the sort of traditional fundamental analysis has to be leavened with a, like, understanding of sort of a n-- the new era of, of sort of financial capital as it works now. 19:08 Mm-hmm. I think that's a, a kind of huge lesson that is being sort of metabolized by the market and has been for a, a while now. But with twenty twenty-four where we see, you know, the market, 19:18 as, uh, John Cook said, like, uh, you know, dou- d- uh, outperform by about double, like the key, like, long-term rate of return in general, you know, uh, from an already high y- uh, high year and years of, you know, market growth, uh, that 19:35 it is a kind of an, a, a new world that the way we still talk about stocks, uh, sometimes doesn't reflect that. Mm. Absolutely. 19:45 It's, it's a very different investing, um, world we live in now than years, decades ago for sure. Um, John C-Cook, I'll let you close us out. 19:56 Um, are there any lessons learned from twenty twenty-four that we could apply in twenty twenty-five in the stock market? Well, we-- we're an ETF shop. We, we're an ETF investment strategist at iSectors. 20:10 We've, we've-- you know, the ETF vehicle structure we've liked for a really long time. 20:14 We kind of-- we've preferred passive investing over active investing, at least in the, you know, equity markets, large cap equity markets for some time. And this year has sort of, to me, reaffirmed that a little bit. 20:26 Um, trying to, to get too fancy, right- Mm-hmm...and, and trying to, um, go against the wave of the market at times in the last two years with all this, as I mentioned earlier, everything else going on, all the noise, um, the markets continue to persist and continue to, you know, throw off these double, twice as, uh, twice the historical norm gains. 20:47 And it's, it's-- it reminds me of a phrase that I've heard fairly recently that it just makes a ton of sense when you're digging into all of the investment processes and you're reading economist research and things. 20:58 Pessimists sound smart, but optimists make money. And that is sort of what I've been thinking about the-- this year. Um, i-if you get too worried, you know, 21:13 the, the-- as with the wars, the Fed, the interest rates, the election, if you would've been too defensive this year, you, you know, you would've been left, left behind. 21:26 [upbeat music] Thank you again to John Cook and John Engel for sharing your insights on the stock market. And thank you to everyone for listening to today's discussion. 21:36 We'll be back next week for another episode of Early Bird. Have a great day. [upbeat music]